filters
state:
Show
city:
Show
product:
Show
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
PSA DNA - 7/8 card sent in poorly graded
I sent in 8 cards in which 7 of them were poorly graded. 6 cards were 1948 bowman basketball, all of which should have graded 7-8 mininum grades. The best condition ones graded 6-7 and the ones that got an 8 grade should have been 7's. My biggest complaint was i sent...
Read more
2.8
I liked
  • Turnaround time
I didn't like
  • Grading was not consistant
#1092156
Reply to reviews
I agree, I had them authenticate a Kawai Leonard Photo, Tim Wakefield baseball and Mike Schmidt photo this weekend at the Cow Palace Tri-Star show and they said they were all not real! and they were all 100% authentic! That's 6 now in the past 2 years that I have...
Read more
1.2
I didn't like
  • Lack of expertise
#1043596
Reply to reviews
PSA DNA making too much on Ebay to let integrity in!
I fisically submitted 5 Donald Trump signatures and two Mike Pence signatures all acquired at campaign stops during the 2016 campaign. To my amazement all returned as "not authentic". Since I have submitted and received three different COAs. Figured faced with this...
Read more
#1021373
Reply to reviews
PSA DNA - Poor customer service
1/1

PSA DNA - Poor customer service

PSA DNA
#1111429
Paid $125 for grading a black lotus. Came back inconclusive and I was still charged. Given a two word explanation on a label sticker. Will use becket next time. Terrible customer service. She basically said they were too busy to talk to me on the phone or give me detailed information on the incomplete grading, but full charge.
Comment
Show

PSA DNA - If autograph doesn't look exactly like what they have on file, they will not authenticate

PSA DNA
#1068170
1.0
Details
Sent in a number of autographed cards to get authenticated and since they didn't look exactly like what they had on file, they deemed not authentic. Would highly recommend not using them as they will take your money and not grade cards.
Comment
Show
Additional Fees
Advertised vs Delivered
Billing Practices
Customer service
Discounts and Special Offers
Diversity of Products or Services
Exchange, Refund and Cancellation Policy
Product or Service Quality
Reliability
Staff
Turnaround Time
Value for money
Warranty
Website

Short Review on December 09, 2016

PSA DNA
#970384
1.1
Details
These guys are scammers.....I had a Donald Trump photo signed right in front of me in New Hampshire....and they responded "questionable authenticity".....its a joke....they dont want ppl making money over their items. Never again.
Comment
Show
Additional Fees
Advertised vs Delivered
Billing Practices
Customer service
Discounts and Special Offers
Diversity of Products or Services
Exchange, Refund and Cancellation Policy
Product or Service Quality
Reliability
Staff
Turnaround Time
Value for money
Warranty
Website

Short Review on April 28, 2016

PSA DNA
#838139
I know a guy who autographed himself two balls , sended to psa came back real. One was Ozzie smith the other Bob Gibson.
Comment
Show
I sent in a Brady that I was sure genuine. Did tons of research put in came back likely not genuine. Told customer that had purchased what happened he told me he knows auto is 110% authentic. Was ticked so went on eBay to see more items to compare some guy has sold 17...
Read more
godofwar021
godofwar021

If your buying brady, have it authenticated by Tri-Star(a company he works with) or James Spence in person authenticator. Don't send off for authentication. Brady cost to much...

#1017907
Reply to reviews
PSA DNA - ASA AKA PSA 9s and LOO
I recently sent 6 2014 Mookie Betts Bowman Chrome BCP #109 all really nice cards to PSA, results--grades one 10, five 9s-no 8.5s or 9.5s all 9s. Protecting their POPS. Another example of ASA keeping the individual Trader in their place. PSA is like playing in a poker...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I sent in a Wade Boggs Rookie Card that was perfect and could only have gotten a minimum grade of 9, but what was sent back to me was a card with bent corners and a crease on ...

#980652
Reply to reviews
I recently sumitted a Jordan #57 to PSA which I had taken out of a pack in 1986. They claimed that the card was "under required size" and would not give it a grade. I am thinking that this card was so nice, they did not want to have it compete with their "regular big...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

Ive been saying that for years. If you aren't sending in PSA 100s if not thousands of cards, your not going to get back well graded cards. They favor high volume clients, over...

#927931
Reply to reviews
I recently switched from BGS to PSA for grading and it has been a horrible experience. First the customer service is rude, one of the reps Veronica hung up the phone twice. The operator tells me they are just an operator and won't connect me to a manager. And...
Read more
2.1
I didn't like
  • False promises
  • No accountability
#926042
Reply to reviews
I shipped my NBA basketball to PSA/DNA. I got it signed in person. Face to Face! I just needed a certificate so I can sell it online. I just received a letter saying my basketball isn't real? WTF!!! I have several pictures of them signing the same exact ball! I took...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I posted a ball for sale on eBay, with sportsmemorabilia.com picture and COA ok, the same exact picture used on their website ok, The sticker shown in picture was JSA BTW, pai...

1.0
I didn't like
  • False promises
#888959
Reply to reviews
PSA DNA - PSA/DNA Quick Opinion is Bogus Opinion
PSA DNA - PSA/DNA Quick Opinion is Bogus Opinion
PSA DNA - PSA/DNA Quick Opinion is Bogus Opinion
PSA DNA - PSA/DNA Quick Opinion is Bogus Opinion
PSA DNA - PSA/DNA Quick Opinion is Bogus Opinion
I had a PSA/DNA Quick Opinion done of a Buzz Aldrin autograph that I got myself in Chicago on June 12; 2016. This was done at the Chicago Tribune Printers Row Lit Fest at the Chcago Public Library. Buzz Aldrin and Christina Korp gave a presentation about Buzz Aldrins...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I have an autographed baseball signed in person by Ted Williams, (Ted was 73 when he signed it) same result as yours-change the P to A for Amateur Sports Authenticator ASA.

1.0
I didn't like
  • Authentic autograph opinion likely not genuine
#867969
Reply to reviews
In a weird twist during testimony of case MID SC-001323015, Middlesex County, NJ, PSA President, Mr. Joe Orlando testifies that in his professional opinion the said damaged ticket was intentionally damaged. Mr. Orlando would mention intentional damage at least 3...
Read more
1.0
I didn't like
  • Possible criminal act of intentional damage
#837647
Reply to reviews